The Mouton Show

Greivis VasquezJoin PlayersVoice this Thursday @ 6:30pm at the Greene Turtle in Laurel, MD for a LIVE taping of the Mouton show as we kick off the ACC Tournament & celebrate the ACC Player and Coach of the Year!

Exclusive Interview

Barry SandersBarry Sanders catches up with Players Voice on Radio Row.

Hear it here ...

Ready, Set, Fail PDF Print E-mail

Jamarcus Russell, Oakland Raiders

by MARK GREY

12.19.09

Who wouldn’t want to be the number one overall pick in an NFL draft?  You get to be the big man in a new city, the future cornerstone of a NFL team, and that seven figure guarantee doesn’t hurt either.  Being selected number one overall means that a bad team is looking for you to lead them to brighter pastures.  So how could being drafted number one ever be a bad thing?  It happens when you’re drafted by Al Davis and the Oakland Raiders.  Once seen as a future franchise quarterback, Jamarcus Russell’s Raiders career is all but over before it even started.

There is no question that at age 24, Russell has played the biggest part in his own demise, but he has had plenty of help.  While being drafted number one overall was the best thing to ever happen to his bank account, it was the worst thing to ever happen to his football career.  Anyone who stopped and studied both Russell’s and the Raiders' background should have known that it was a match made in hell.

After a few unsuccessful years of playing musical chairs with over-the-hill quarterbacks, Raiders owner Al Davis was determined to find a young quarterback to lead his team into the future.  Thanks to another bad season, the Raiders owned the number one pick in the 2007 draft and there was Russell sitting there with all the bells and whistles that Davis loves.  Russell was a dominating physical presence under center, and could throw the ball further from his knee than some quarterbacks could standing up.  Although most draft experts agreed he was raw and far from the best player in the draft, good ol’ Al made him the number one pick overall and from that point on, Russell was destined to fail.

The first problem in Russell’s failures was that he should never have been drafted number 1.  Being drafted first overall comes with extremely high expectations -- expectations that Russell wasn’t gifted enough to meet.  David Carr said it best, “When you’re drafted number one, you’re expected to be great.”  The problem is, Russell is never going to be great.  If Russell was drafted in a later round and placed in the right environment with lower expectations, he had enough talent to be a solid starter a few years down the road.  Russell, who was 21 at the time he was drafted, needed to sit a few years and learn the NFL game from an established veteran to earn the respect of his teammates and coaching staff.  He needed to learn what it means to be a leader of men on and off the field.  In short, he needed time to grow as a player and a person, which is not something the Raiders are known for.

After already being drafted way higher than he should have been, Russell made things worse with a hold-out that lasted into the regular season.  At a time when Russell should have been at camp learning the offense and earning his teammates' respect, he was at home fighting about money he hadn’t even earned yet.  By the time Russell finally joined the team, he was so far behind that any hopes of him contributing to the season were all but lost.  By his second season, the team had turned into a full zoo, with the owner and coach feuding and Russell stuck in the middle.  The head coach was being forced to play Russell even though he didn’t want to and was facing questions about his job weekly.  One of the biggest things all young quarterbacks need is stability and the Raiders had become anything but that.  The head coach was fired in the middle of the season and the Raiders became nothing more than a media circus.  Despite all of that, Russell still had a decent sophomore season, but he still had a long way to go.

By the start of his third season, Russell had seen just about everything except the norm.  His first coach had been fired and his current coach was facing assault charges for beating up another coach.  If all of that wasn’t enough, for some reason, the team drafted a receiver seventh overall who some draft experts didn’t even expect to be drafted in the first round.  In three seasons, Davis had surrounded Russell with more drama than talent.  The only thing worse than the Raiders' off-the-field issues was Russell’s play on it.  When he wasn’t struggling to make the right reads, Russell was over throwing open receivers by 10 yards.  Once known as a somewhat mobile quarterback, he has gotten so big that he can no longer even get out of his own way and appears like he is running in sand while everyone else is on turf.  He has proven to be anything but a leader with quotes like, “I’m not the problem,” and his level of play has gone down while his weight has gone up.

By naming Charlie Frye this week's starter, it appears that the Raiders have seen enough of Russell right now to know that he is not their future.  Al Davis is disappointed that Russell never progressed, but in hindsight, why would he?  What lessons has he learned since turning pro?  He showed up for the NFL combine 10 pounds over weight and is rewarded by being the number one pick.  He misses all of training camp and the preseason and is rewarded with 68 million dollars and even starts before the season is over.  The following year, his coach doesn’t think he is good enough to play, so the owner fires the coach and tells the world Jamarcus is a great player.  If Jamarcus was a child and Al Davis was his father, someone would call child services on him.  Davis has done just about everything to assure that Russell does not grow into a great quarterback.  Critics say he hasn’t matured, but how could he?  Who at the Raiders facility is he learning from?  For every one reason you can name for why he should be great, you can name 15 reasons why he shouldn’t be.  For the last half of this decade, the Raiders have continued to draft players who never live up to their expectations and can’t just be them.  The problem with recent Raiders top draft pick is, they are all drafted higher than they should be, and then thrown into an environment that doesn’t foster their growth.  I have no idea who the Raiders' first pick will be next year, but all I can say is good luck...and save your money.
Comments
Add New Search
R8er_nation   |2009-12-26 16:01:47
"Who at the Raiders facility is he learning from?" really?? well how
about Paul Hackett?? does that ring a bell!! He's one of the best QB coaches out
there! Gradkowski didnt seem to have a problem. If Gradkowski would have played
earlier, you're telling me he would NOT have made the diff in two or three games
to be in the middle of the playoff hunt?? the Raiders are getting better!!
Russell does not have the work ethic and that is on him!!!
Checkers not Chess   |2009-12-20 09:50:24
IMO Russell sucks and was overrated out of college. That being said im not sure
anyone would have succeeded in his situation. What kind of coaching staff lets
you play no matter how out of shape you are. He needs be on a team where is held
accountable for his actions and just hasnt been. He was never going to be good
but i think he could have been better then this.
Joke   |2009-12-20 09:41:25
Russell is a joke and the Raiders are a joke. Perfect match.
Raiderd4life   |2009-12-20 09:36:28
I completely disagree. As an established college player, regardless of the team
around you, you must show your personal skill set. Not just your throwing
ability, reading defenses and accuracy but your leadership abilities,
adaptability and motivational skills. Once his rookie holdout was done and he
got some chances to play, he definitely showed he had some football skills to
build on. then, his first year starting was a bit rough but once the team
settled down he seemed to show some motivational skills as well as leadership
ability. His total stats make his 2009 stats that much more horrible. His main
problem this season is he has truly regressed.

Even when he has had his
chances with guys around him making plays he has been unable to sustain any
consistency. If you look at individual plays, he just doesn't show good
accuracy, aniticipation on his throws or that he has worked on his craft. He has
two coaches (T.Tollner and P.Hackett) that are considered gurus with QB's and he
can't get better? He has shown no commitment to being the leader of his team.
Like it or not, a QB has to do that. For him to not have a personal trainer,
personal QB coach, personal speech coach and some type of mento to sow him the
ropes off the field is beyond me. Yes, a speech coach. To be the best, you have
to talk, walk, think, act and look like a pro QB.

He needs to dedicate
himself personally to being the best. He truly has yet to do that. List all of
the starting QB's in this league and they all look, act, talk and walk the part.
That is a personal decision. Not a team thing, management thing or owner thing.
Our team deflated in the 2nd half against Washington for one reason only.
Because J.Russell was in the game. He looked just like he always has
unfortunately. Too flat.

Stand him next to B.Gradkowski and C.Frye and who
looks like a pro QB? He does. Put him on the field now against those two and who
inspires his team, makes playes when needed, motivates the guys and shows a
spark? Not J.Russell. That is his problem. Give your team a reason to not bring
in replacements for your position. Competition, yes. To bring in 3 replacements
this year? Devastating.
I comprehend   |2009-12-20 09:32:14
No matter how good you might be today, no matter how much potential you may have
later, if you get drafted by the Raiders, stack your money because your career
will be short-lived. The only thing the Raiders are good at is being bad. They
lack leadership and the cohesiveness as a team to make or sustain anyone's
career.
LA Faithful   |2009-12-20 09:28:19
Agreed to a point. I believe that the blame can be spread 75/25... with the
majority of it going to Russell.

JR doomed himself from the get go. My thing
is, if Russell and everyone else believed he wasn't the best pick in the draft
then why hold out? Why not be grateful and do what you can to get to work
immediately? Greed and immaturity, not the quality of a leader. It doesn't help
that he's lazy and in my opinion stupid. The only time he seemed decent was when
the playbook was half way open to him, but how long do you run an offense that
way? Baltimore didn't wait long with Flacco and he is making it happen.

In
his defense, our O line sucked and he didn't have very many credible receivers.
That being said though, Gradkowski has made both elements look very good at
times, so I don't think Russell can rest his case on that too much.

Drafting
him number one WAS a mistake, but its time to our losses. The team won't follow
him and the fans won't support him. He's done in Oakland.
R Nation   |2009-12-20 08:58:02
You can't bring a QB into a place where there was no O-Line, WR, or good RBs. I
think if he were to come into the league today he would be better because he has
a better O-Line, McFadden, Bush, Fargas at RB and has Schilens, Murphy and
Miller to throw the ball to
Clouden   |2009-12-19 21:29:43
Fitting title for Russell..he said he was embarrassed when he was benched by
Cable and said his weight and work ethic aren't a problem and that he will not
renegotiate his contract to take less money than he is owed,like you said being
the big man in the city and #1 draft pick really went to the head.If the raiders
were smart they would save their money like you said or else they would invest
in another Russell, who if he doesn't throw another pass this season, will be
the first quarterback since 1998 to have a rating under 50 with at least 200
attempts. Good article.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.22 Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 

Speak On It

Mr. BrewskyThis week Mr. Brewsky talks about NFL free agents, March Madness, The Combine and much more.

Hear it here.

NBA Image "The definition of a good trade is one that makes both teams better.  By that definition, there are very few trades in sports that are good.  Looking back at the Gasol trade now, there is no denying that both teams got what they were looking for"  Read More...

All Star Revival

Derrick RoseHorse is a game kids play outside in elementary school at recess.  It just doesn’t translate well to grown men playing inside.  Watching NBA players shoot one-handed free throws and other dumb shots is like inviting Tony Stewart and Jimmie Johnson over and seeing who is better at parallel parking.  It’s a waste of everyone’s time.  Read More...

NFL Image
"Is Orton a better quarterback then Cutler?  The combine, the stats, and the highlight reels say no, but the records say yes.  Will Orton ever be able to throw the ball 60 yards across his body and hit a double covered receiver right between the numbers?   No, but he also won’t try to three or four times a game."   Read More ...

GraysonBoucher.net

Poll Question

Is the UCONN womens dominance good for womens basketball ?
 

This Week @ the Barbershop

The Barbershop

The boys discuss LT, Wetbrook, NBA Trades, and Much More 
 Hear More...

College Football Begins Here - Signing Day and Coaching Controversies

 Steve AddazioIt didn’t take Kiffin long to stir things up at USC as he and his staff have already been reprimanded for recruiting practices. USC will be good because they have the talent. They will be great because, despite all the controversy, Kiffin and his staff are among the best in football.   Read More ...
Players Voice Logo

NCAA Coaching Carousel: A thrill ride at whose expense?

Lane Kiffin

The NCAA has grown into a money hungry machine that harnesses the hard work, aspirations and overall performance of young men.  The amount of money that programs make off of television contracts and ticket sales is off the charts.  For amateur athletic competition, the NCAA sure does make a lot of money.  Read More ...

Death of the Sports Icon

Henry Aaron (left) Ted Williams (right)
Can it really be that there will never be another true sports icon again?  If our elders have their way, there won’t be.  We have respected their sports heroes our entire lives, but they refuse to let ours reach the same level.  Read More ...
6thMAN