The Mouton Show

Greivis VasquezJoin PlayersVoice this Thursday @ 7pm at the Greene Turtle in Laurel, MD for a LIVE taping of the Mouton show as we kick off the ACC Tournament!

Exclusive Interview

Barry SandersBarry Sanders catches up with Players Voice on Radio Row.

Hear it here ...

Half Man Half Machine: Peyton Manning PDF Print E-mail

Peyton Manning

by MARK GREY

10.28.09

Coming into the 2009 season, the title of “Best QB” was very much up for debate.  Just about everyone had Tom Brady and Peyton Manning as 1 and 1a with Drew Brees a close second.  The argument has always been Manning’s stats or Brady’s rings.  No matter which way you went on the issue, there really was no wrong answer because they were both great players.  It may have been unclear who was number one entering the season, but the answer couldn’t be clearer now.  For those who still don’t know, here’s a hint: his last name rhymes with planning.

In a year where many were looking for Manning’s play to take a step back, he has actually taken his game to a higher level.  For years, Manning had found himself surrounded with talent.  He has had all pro running backs to hand the ball off to and his choice of pro bowl receivers to throw to.  The question was how he would perform this season without his star studded cast.  Marvin Harrison, the future Hall of Fame weapon who had been with Manning his entire career, is now gone and the running game ranks 28th in the league; yet Manning hasn’t missed a beat.  As if Manning hadn’t already been stripped of enough of his weapons, in week one he lost Anthony Gonzalez before he even got a chance to catch a pass.  The loss of all these weapons would be enough to affect most QBs' performances, but Manning is proving he is not most QBs.

The performance Peyton has put on through the first seven weeks of this season is nothing short of amazing. While Brees and Brady have both had record breaking games this season in which they threw for 6 touchdowns, it is Manning’s consistency that has set him apart.  Brady and Brees have both had games this season they would like to forget with QB ratings under 60, but Manning's lowest QB rating in any game this season is 94. In most games, Manning resembles a robot more than a human, picking apart defenses with ease.  No quarterback has ever finished a season completing more than 71 percent of his passes and Manning is currently at 72 percent.

While it is not unusual to be beaten by a great quarterback on Sunday, Manning has most of his opponents beaten by Saturday night.  With the amount of time Manning spends preparing for each team, it’s beginning to look like playing on Sunday is the easy part.  Watching Manning play is almost like playing against the computer on a video game; he already knows what you're going to do and how to counter it.  There is no one better in the game at making pre-snap reads than Manning and it seems like he is only getting better.  For years he put up eye popping numbers while throwing to the likes of Reggie Wayne, Brandon Stokley and Harrison, but now he is having his best season with receivers that most football fans have never heard of.  Manning always seems to know the right play to call to get one of his receivers open, and even when there isn’t, he still finds a way to get the ball in there.  Last weekend tight end Dallas Clark was double covered and somehow Manning found a way to put the ball where only he could catch it.

Manning appears to have reached a level of mastery that is rarely seen in sports.  Michael Jordan once described it as no longer playing a sport, it’s more like a chess match with your opponent;  a level in which the game is won just as much mentally as it is physically. You often hear about great players reaching the point when the game begins to slow down for them.  If the game gets any slower for Peyton, it will stop.  He appears to see every blitz before it comes and is able to read every zone to the T.  In 215 pass attempts, Manning has only been sacked twice, which not only speaks volumes about the great job his offensive line is doing, but also shows his ability to avoid the blitzes with his play calling.

It is great to see that Brady is returning to his MVP form and Brees and the Saints seem to put up 50 points every week, but what Manning is doing is truly special.  No one player in the NFL is more responsible for his team's success than Manning, and he wouldn’t have it any other way.  Manning may look like the least athletic player on the field on any given Sunday, but he more than makes up for it by being the most prepared player every single week.  After all, does a robot really have to be athletic?    

 
Comments
Add New Search
BleedColtsBlue  - Manning Sucks.   |2010-02-14 19:06:32
This is the REAL BleedColtsBlue here, and I think Manning is no where NEAR the
best the game has ever seen.

Him throwing away the super bowl this year is
just another in a long line of Manning playoff failures.

Go Colts!!!!
C. Max   |2009-12-10 13:00:31
I been sayin Peyton was my boy. lol
slim   |2009-11-22 02:26:27
manning is the best qb to ever touch the field sorry dan and joe...please stop
comparing him 2 brady well written though ive always felt this way..
Josepi75  - Manning is great, but...   |2009-11-12 12:00:19
Nobody can argue that Manning isn't an elite quarterback in today's game, but I
still think he's even with Brady.
What Manning is doing this year, Brady
already did. Playing with the likes of Reche Caldwell and Jabar Gaffney as the
top recievers in 06 was a far more difficult task than what Manning has now.
Atleast Reggie Wayne is a top notch reciever and Dallas Clark is among the elite
pass catching TEs. Brady got to the AFC Championship game with a bunch of
castoffs. I won't use the weak division that Indi plays in to diminish Manning's
season. I think the AFC East was pretty pathetic in 06 too.
As Brady rounds
back into his former self this year, it will once again be a "does it really
matter" debate.
Crazy Dolphin!!!!   |2009-11-02 13:01:09
He's good, but he's no Dan Marino!!!!!!

Dolphin 4 Life!!!!!
Indy 2007   |2009-10-30 10:37:57
I agree Peyton is the best cyborg the nfl has ever seen. I heard everymorning
before practice he eats his wheaties and punches Chuck Norris in the face. No
human could do that.....he has to be part robot
Indy Jack   |2009-10-30 10:36:54
Let us all please remember that Mr. Manning has taken a group of nobody
receivers (i.e. Pierre Garcon; 205th pick out of Mount Union, Austin Collie;
127th pick out of BYU) and made them legitimate threats. If you research his
career, as a whole, you will see that he has always made those around him
better. And please let us not forget that he puts those ridiculous numbers up
with no running game.
Anonymous   |2009-10-30 10:36:03
The AFCS has the most wins of any division since realignment. Take that to the
bank.
Hype   |2009-10-30 10:34:14
Benefits from playing in the weakest division in the AFC.
Anonymous   |2009-10-29 20:53:04
Enjoy the performance people.
Week after week Peyton is the Best hands down.We
may never see this Great consistant level of play again.
I have been watching
football for 48 years and have seen all the great ones play.
He's The
Best.
Savior it while you can.
I certainly will.
LC  - Peyton Manning is the Best   |2009-10-28 22:54:46
Nice read

Manning is obviously the best QB ever

Instead of talking about
how many rings Montana or Brady have, let's talk about how many TDs or passing
yards they have

Sure...rings are indicative of one's success...but sustained
individual excellence means just as much

Manning has a ring and Manning will
have the records...ain't nothing Brady or anyone else can do to surpass that
Mr. Bojangles  - Indeed   |2009-10-28 20:29:37
Brady's defense and special teams took a very good QB to an elite level. Peyton
does the exact opposite. He makes those around HIM that much better.
Southdodger   |2009-10-28 18:33:18
I think it is accurate to describe Manning as the greatest regular season QB
ever. However, I believe he is ranked #11 in passer efficiency in the playoffs.
Also, Brady is only sixth or seventh himself in the playoffs. He has not been
outstanding either. Both QBs have several years left. Brady has virtually no
chance, nor does any other QB, of reaching what Manning will be putting up in
his regular season career, but it would be nice for Manning to get another ring
and a post season of around 125 in passer rating. That would put him right at
the top of post season passer ratings as well. He is very capable of that.
CanadianColt   |2009-10-28 18:31:05
I just wish Manning is more Machine during the playoffs instead of the regular
season.
Ian   |2009-10-28 18:29:51
Good read. I love the "When it is not unusual to get beat by a great
quarterback on Sunday, Manning has most of his opponents beat by Saturday
night" line!
Anonymous   |2009-10-28 18:28:08
Best regular season stat QB in the NFL. Total fraud in postseason. One-and-done
Peyton has 6 of them to his credit. More than anyone in NFL history
LLcoolRay   |2009-10-28 16:08:38
Half man, half god, half.... possible centaur. I'm not sure, but either way, I
wish he was my dad.
rayted32   |2009-10-28 16:07:40
It just shows to go you that, when you mix determination, intellect and a great
arm with having a daddy and mommy who raise football players and good human
beings...that THIS is the result. We should ALL be so fortunate!
Tre   |2009-10-28 16:05:54
it was a nice read thanks for posting . . . its just amazing what some elite
athetles can accompish
Colts Rule   |2009-10-28 16:04:40
Awesome read!!
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.22 Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 

Speak On It

Mr. BrewskyThis week Mr. Brewsky talks about NFL free agents, March Madness, The Combine and much more.

Hear it here.

NBA Image "The definition of a good trade is one that makes both teams better.  By that definition, there are very few trades in sports that are good.  Looking back at the Gasol trade now, there is no denying that both teams got what they were looking for"  Read More...

All Star Revival

Derrick RoseHorse is a game kids play outside in elementary school at recess.  It just doesn’t translate well to grown men playing inside.  Watching NBA players shoot one-handed free throws and other dumb shots is like inviting Tony Stewart and Jimmie Johnson over and seeing who is better at parallel parking.  It’s a waste of everyone’s time.  Read More...

NFL Image
"Is Orton a better quarterback then Cutler?  The combine, the stats, and the highlight reels say no, but the records say yes.  Will Orton ever be able to throw the ball 60 yards across his body and hit a double covered receiver right between the numbers?   No, but he also won’t try to three or four times a game."   Read More ...

GraysonBoucher.net

Poll Question

Is the UCONN womens dominance good for womens basketball ?
 

This Week @ the Barbershop

The Barbershop

The boys discuss LT, Wetbrook, NBA Trades, and Much More 
 Hear More...

College Football Begins Here - Signing Day and Coaching Controversies

 Steve AddazioIt didn’t take Kiffin long to stir things up at USC as he and his staff have already been reprimanded for recruiting practices. USC will be good because they have the talent. They will be great because, despite all the controversy, Kiffin and his staff are among the best in football.   Read More ...
Players Voice Logo

NCAA Coaching Carousel: A thrill ride at whose expense?

Lane Kiffin

The NCAA has grown into a money hungry machine that harnesses the hard work, aspirations and overall performance of young men.  The amount of money that programs make off of television contracts and ticket sales is off the charts.  For amateur athletic competition, the NCAA sure does make a lot of money.  Read More ...

Death of the Sports Icon

Henry Aaron (left) Ted Williams (right)
Can it really be that there will never be another true sports icon again?  If our elders have their way, there won’t be.  We have respected their sports heroes our entire lives, but they refuse to let ours reach the same level.  Read More ...
6thMAN